I have not used Math-U-See. I'm aware that the author has worked hard to develop a good course. Folks generally stay with it through algebra and geometry. I don't get many kids with a Math-U-See background.
Saxon is fine for kids who like hard work for the sake of hard work. It's ok up through the Algebra 1/2 book, but the algebra book takes the idea of cycling back to review one step too far. It strikes me as somewhat helter-skelter, and I refuse to teach from it or to tutor kids from it. The subsequent high school books are just as frustrating. Still, I know some kids who had a good guide (parent who was good with math) to get them through algebra with Saxon, and were fine.
Here's what I DO use for pre-algebra:
1. The homeschool group I administrate uses the reproducible worksheets from Steve and Janis Marcy, http://www.marcymathworks.com. These include everything that might be taught in general math and pre-algebra, but don't include instructions. They are thorough and complete, however, covering all of the needed topics. A savvy parent will enjoy these. If they need directions I have kids write directions on the back of a sheet.
2. The Mental Math series on Amazon:
These are also reproducible. They are a nice balance to developing proficiency with a calculator. Kids DO need to develop proficiency with a calculator!
3. There are a lot of $6 workbooks that can be found at Barnes and Noble, sometimes Toys R Us for keeping things fresh over the summer, and these are JUST FINE for regular use. Each book focuses on a topic, like fractions, decimals, graphing, etc. Use them up, throw them away, buy them again for the next kid. There also are some very good supplemental books by the Critical Thinking publishers. Here's one:
4. I have recommended ALEKS.com as an online website for use by adults needing to refresh and re-learn concepts from pre-algebra forward. The ALEKS folks have been diligent at filling in the gaps and developing coursework, and the system is VERY good at diagnosing gaps in learning and understanding and drilling to fill those in. At $20 per month, it is the cheapest math tutoring I know. I've sent some folks out to ALEKS to polish some skills before they enter classes at the community college, and I've learned that if ALEKS says they know the material, then they know the material. The ALEKS folks have developed their online materials for kids as soon as they can read. I haven't reviewed that level, but I wouldn't park a kid in front of a computer for a long period of time, anyway. Some will eat it up, however.
The most important part of pre-algebra is showing where it is used all of the time. That's where homeschooling is excellent, if parents aren't stuck in the classroom paradigm, thinking that math education has to be done at a table with a book. Going to the grocery store, shopping online for a good deal, measuring and weighing and cutting in the kitchen and Dad's shop, comparing cellular contracts, talking about the good deal vs. the right fit, on and on. If parents know how to use the math in everyday life, the kids will be just fine.
When to start Algebra? Whenever the student is ready. The big rush is to put it into the 8th grade for everyone. Huge mistake. It just means I'll be teaching at the community college until I die, if I like, cleaning up the mess made by pushing it too soon. I would say that if a young student has competence in all of the topics in anyone's pre-algebra text and is hungry for more, then let him or her begin, but without the necessity of finishing in a year. I've had students as young as 6th grade in the Jacobs book (I have one now that age), but I find that as bright as they may be, they need more time to digest and complete homework. For that reason, I have designed a Decompressed Algebra series, which takes two years to complete the book, and provides lots of opportunities for data gathering and analysis, along the lines suggested by exercises in the book.
Good, solid, math fun? Play games! The card game War is how my kids learned to sequence and count. I've developed matching cards for fractions-decimals-percents, and my pre-algebra class has been playing Go Fish with these for two weeks. Yahtzee, Sequence, Rack-O, Flinch. Checkers, Chess, Go, Oware. These are every bit as important as drill and practice.
But you knew all this!
No comments:
Post a Comment